Why are my Carrots Short and Fat? (Definitive Answer)

This post may contain affiliate links

If your homemade carrots are short and fat instead of long and thin, there are a few easy tricks you may use to produce long, straight carrots if you love carrots and want to cultivate your own. Sometimes, planted carrots don’t come out the way we want them to.

One of the most common crops grown in gardens is the carrot, but when production issues arise, many gardeners are let down. Carrot cultivation issues are rather typical, and most of them are preventable.

Carrots that are short and fat often have one of two causes: either the seed was planted for a kind that develops in this fashion, or the growth conditions weren’t perfect for the carrot. This essay will go over all you need to know to produce huge, delicious carrots rather than short, obese ones.

How to prevent short and fat carrots

Most types of carrots are flat and round, fat and short, and come in hues like purple, yellow and white, but many others can be long, slim, and orange. You may cultivate the ideal soil conditions for long, flat carrots by following these straightforward suggestions.

Type of soil

Clay soil can be challenging for carrots to penetrate. Instead of producing long, slim carrots, this may produce short, fatty ones. Inserting old compost into clay soil will improve it. Thus, the soil will become lighter, enabling the carrots to grow deeper.

Carrots will naturally grow longer on lighter soils with a larger proportion of loam or sand. To improve the soil’s ability to retain water, it is advisable to include modest amounts of compost. To prevent lumps, stir well.

Examine your soil and fertilizer.

Carrot growth is significantly influenced by the kind of soil utilized. Carrots thrive on loose, wet soil that has been tilled down to a depth of around 1 foot. A soil with a lot of stones and twigs should be avoided since they will prevent root growth.

Soil moisture for healthy carrots

The optimal conditions for growing carrots are wet, well-drained soil. Dry times can limit the growth of carrots, leading them to become broader and thicker rather than extending deeper into the soil. For the first few weeks, ensure the carrot seedlings are moist.

You may water the carrots manually to keep them growing if there isn’t much spring rain.

Soil pH for carrots

Check the pH balance to ensure that your soil is not overly acidic. The ideal pH balance for the soil where you want to grow carrots is between 6 and 6.5.

Avoid applying fertilizers with excessive nitrogen levels as they may result in carrots with many leaves and short or weak roots.

Carrot growth ideal air condition

Readings around 60 and 70 ° Fahrenheit are ideal for carrot growth. After the final big frost in the spring, they are prepared for planning. Your carrots could not be as large or possibly have a strong, disagreeable flavor if you reside in a location where the temperature is too high.

See also  How to Grow Corbaci Pepper (Full Guide)

Your carrots might get thinner and longer in the early spring if the temperature where you live falls below 55 degrees Fahrenheit.


Carrot development might be hampered by soil that contains a lot of twigs and stones. Their root will be sent in the opposite direction when it encounters a rock, causing the carrot to grow sideways. Additionally, rocks can make the carrot shorter and thicker by preventing the root from growing deeper.

Work the soil carefully before sowing carrot seeds. If the soil is tilled down to a depth of around one foot, carrots will grow longer and flatter.

Don’t use fresh manure

When the cooler months of the growing season, notably spring and fall, approach, carrots thrive in loose, sandy soil. Never apply fresh manure to the soil since it might cause the carrot roots to split and grow smaller than usual.

Additionally, the excess nitrogen in fresh manure can burn carrot roots and impede their growth.

Directly sow carrot seeds in the soil.

The best technique to ensure that carrot seeds grow long and straight is to plant them directly into the soil. The roots of carrot seedlings may bend when they are relocated, which may hinder them from developing longer.

Instead of producing long, thin carrots, this may cause them to become short and plump.

The spacing between the seeds should be roughly one centimeter. Seed germination is influenced by soil temperature. At roughly 10 degrees Celsius, germination should take 10 days.

To get the spacing perfect, try using carrot tape. The uniformly distributed carrot seeds are enclosed in a biodegradable membrane that disintegrates over time.

Consequently, there will be less thinning and no grafting, which may alter their form.

After your seedlings start to sprout, you should cover them with 3 to 4 inches of mulch. The soil will be improved while remaining wet as a result.

Carrots should be left in the ground until they are fully mature.

Carrots typically take two to four months to develop, so planting them in the spring or summer will ensure you have an abundance of them in the fall. Allow the carrot to remain in the ground so that the roots may develop deeply. The carrots will then swell and get tastier.

Early carrot harvesting might result in short carrots rather than lengthy ones. Before you pull the carrot out, make sure the top is intact. To determine the size of the base, gently push the dirt away from the top of the stem.

Examine your crops for insects and other pests

Examine your crops for insects and other pests that are damaging them. Rats, flea beetles, weevils, and carrot root are some common pests. The plant is eaten by insects, which also carry potentially deadly illnesses.

Try using a floating row cover to keep insects away while still allowing sunshine and rain to reach the plants as an alternative to using possibly harmful pesticides. Rats are known to consume carrot crops. They love carrots as a treat.

Conditions for thin carrots

Throughout the growth season, thin the carrots numerous times to allow them enough space to grow and the nutrients they need to develop properly.
To make sure there is enough space in the soil for the other carrots to develop correctly, this entails removing a portion of the carrot.

See also  Top 12 Best Fruit Trees to Grow in Georgia in 2023

During the growth season, thinning ought to be done twice to three times. Carrots should be planted around two weeks before to the anticipated last frost, and then you should plant them every three weeks until early October. You will consistently receive a crop of carrots if you do this.

If treated properly, carrots may be preserved for a very long period. Before storage, wash the carrots to increase air circulation and get rid of any bugs that might hasten the rotting process.

Cool carrots down immediately to roughly 40 degrees Fahrenheit to increase their shelf life. Storage conditions for carrots should be at 32 degrees Fahrenheit and 99 percent relative humidity.

Additionally, they will fare better if kept away from fruit that releases ethylene, such as apples and pears, as this causes browning.

Carrots Varieties

Why are my Carrots Short and FatPin

Knowing the many varieties of carrots can help you choose which to grow. The following are some of the most popular carrot varieties:

Chantenay carrots

Why are my Carrots Short and Fat - Carrot varietiesPin

Heavy soil is beneficial for these carrots. They grow to a length of around six to seven inches and are suitable for gardeners who don’t have optimal soil. To obtain the finest flavor, make sure to pluck them early.

Danvers Carrots

They can grow in a variety of soil types, including clay soil, and are tall and slender. They are often orange, although occasionally they might be various colors. They got their name because Danvers, Massachusetts, is where they were created.

The carrot emperor

These carrots are often seen in supermarket stores. They are sweeter than other kinds, and their leaves, which develop more quickly than those of other varieties of carrots, are one of the features that distinguish and partially distinguish them.

Tiny carrots

There are many different sorts of micro carrots, which are different from baby carrots, which are full-size sliced carrots. Some are really sweet and small, like radish. Because of their size, they thrive in containers.

Nantes carrots

Why are my Carrots Short and FatPin

These are completely cylindrical from top to bottom, unlike conventional carrots, and are called for the region of France where they thrive.

They are a crisp, delicious, low-maintenance crop.  Carrots come in enough types to appeal to everyone’s tastes, so you may choose according to your own preferences and the sort of land you have.

Share the image below on your Pinterest board if you find this article on carrots useful!

Why are my Carrots Short and FatPin


Growing carrots with your family at home is enjoyable. They are inexpensive to start from seed and will repay you with a tasty harvest in the spring and fall.

It might be challenging to grow precisely shaped carrots, but strive for soil that has mature compost added, is properly tilled, and is maintained at a constant moisture level. You will have sweet, tasty carrots that are long and lean as a result.

Leave a Comment

Share to...